Stay Informed

Sign up to receive the Middle East Bulletin!

Support Middle East Progress

In-Depth Coverage

Original Commentaries

12/11/08
Toward Resolution  —President of Israel Shimon Peres. Interview with Middle East Bulletin.
11/25/08
U.S. Engagement with Iran: A How to Guide  — Karim Sadjadpour, associate, Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. Original Commentary for Middle East Bulletin.
11/20/08
Pakistan: Learning the Right Lessons from Iraq  —Senator Robert P. Casey, Jr. (D-PA), Senate Foreign Relations Committee. Original Commentary for Middle East Bulletin.

Setting the Record Straight

A Shared Interest

"With his enthusiastic embrace of the so-called Saudi peace plan, Olmert is committing Israel to accepting the Arab narrative of the Arab-Israeli conflict. … With Olmert now giving his stamp of approval to the Saudi plan, he is denying the country its moral right to defend itself both militarily and diplomatically."
—Caroline Glick, deputy managing editor, The Jerusalem Post; senior fellow for Middle Eastern Affairs, Center for Security Policy, "Tzipi and the Drug Lords," The Jerusalem Post, November 27, 2008 versus
  • “Israel rejected the Initiative in the past without examining it in depth. According to the common wisdom, the more Arab partners involved, the more they’ll be pushing us and be in favor of the Palestinians. I think that in the present situation in the Arab and Muslim world, where we see strengthening of extremism that bothers moderate Arab states no less than it bothers us, the Arab states have an interest that such an agreement comes to fruition. And for that to happen, if there is a need to push the Palestinians or assist them, I think this is exactly the time to do that.”
    —Maj. Gen (ret.) Danny Rothschild, president, Council for Peace and Security, interview, Israeli radio, Reshet Bet, November 2, 2008 (translated by Middle East Bulletin)
  • Middle East Analysis

    • Putting the Arab Peace Initiative Into Action —Ghaith al-Omari, director of advocacy, American Task Force on Palestine; former foreign policy adviser to Palestinian President Abbas. Original Commentary for Middle East Bulletin.
    • Peace Plan Needs PR Backing —Roula Khalaf (Financial Times)
    • A Comprehensive Agenda —Ezzedine Choukri-Fishere, former adviser to the Egyptian foreign minister, & Omar Dajani, former legal adviser to the Palestinian negotiating team (Al-Ahram Weekly)
    November 13, 2008

    Egyptian efforts to bring the warring Palestinian factions into a national reconciliation dialogue suffered a setback this week. After receiving assurances by Hamas leaders inside and outside Gaza that the Islamic movement would participate in the planned reconciliation dialogue session in Cairo on November 10, Hamas reversed its position. …

    Cairo is fuming; the last thing the Egyptian leadership wanted was a public snub from Hamas. It had secured the movement’s approval of a proposed reconciliation framework before making it public. Egyptian officials privately blame hardliners inside Hamas— particularly the military wing—as well as their regional sponsors. While Cairo has de facto suspended its mediation efforts and allowed rumors to circulate that it would not resume them before the Israeli elections, it remains clear that Egypt cannot stand idly by and watch the Palestinian rift deepen.

    As time passes, the parties become more entrenched. Inside Hamas, there are those who see no point in reconciliation: the status quo in Gaza offers Hamas space to maneuver, as well as regional and international relevance. Abbas and Fatah are running out of steam, and it is only a matter of time before Hamas makes inroads in the West Bank. Inside Fatah, there are those who take comfort at seeing Hamas choking on its cadeaux empoisonné. Reconciliation, from their point of view, would rescue Hamas from Gaza’s unsolvable problems and from its deadly isolation—and would oblige Fatah leaders to return to haggling over the wording of a national unity program. The ideological rigidity of Hamas and its regional allies make it impossible for the Islamist movement to adopt a realistic policy. Therefore, it is best to leave it with the unbearable weight of the Gaza Strip. Access the full article>>